I just love apple butter. Â But to be honest, I’ve never made it. Â And even though we’ve not had a taste of that cooler fall weather yet, I’m craving some of those delicious flavors of the season – apple, cinnamon – you know what I mean. Â
So I jumped over to JustaPinch.com and found this recipe for Homemade Apple Butter from home cook Gail Herbest.
Now, I’ve always just been satisfied with the store-bought apple butter, but I had no idea just how delicious it could be. Â Nor did I know how easy. Â I mean, this recipe is made in the slow cooker for goodness sake!
This stuff is amazing – perfectly sweet, but a touch tart. Â And I was worried that the spices wouldn’t be enough, but there were plenty to give it the perfect warm flavors I wanted.
The most time consuming thing for this recipe is peeling all the apples. Â But I pulled out my trusty apple peeler/corer (best $13 I ever spent) and it made quick work of the task. Â Since it also slices, I had 6 pounds of apples peeled, cored, and chopped in about 10 minutes.
Gail’s recipe is perfection.  That said, I did make a few little tweaks that are worth mentioning.  Her original recipe called for 5 ½ pound of apples, but since most markets sell apples in 3 pound bags, I used 6 pounds and it worked out perfectly.  I also used an immersion blender to puree the mixture to a smoother consistency.  But that’s it.  It’s hard to fix perfection, right?
This stuff is seriously amazing on hot biscuits, toast, over pound cake, just a spoon – you name it. Â And it makes about 6 cups so you’ll have plenty to share with family and friends. Â You can also can this using the water bath method to save it even longer. Â Y’all enjoy!
Ingredients
- 6 pounds apples (I used about 16 Fuji apples)
- 1 cup sugar
- ½ cup firmly packed brown sugar
- 2 teaspoons ground cinnamon
- ¼ teaspoon ground cloves
- ¼ teaspoon salt
Instructions
- Peel, core, and finely chop the apples.
- Add the apples to the crock of a 6-quart slow cooker. Add the sugars, cinnamon, cloves, and salt. Mix well. Cover and cook on high for 1 hour, then reduce the heat to low and cook for 10 hours, stirring occasionally.
- Uncover and stir well. Â It should be thick and dark brown. Â If you prefer a smoother apple butter, you can use an immersion blender to puree the mixture. Â Leave the lid off and cook for an additional hour on low to allow the mixture to thicken even more. Â
- To store, allow the apple butter to cool, then place in sealable containers or jars and refrigerate for a few weeks or freeze for even longer.
* If nutritional values are provided, they are an estimate and will vary depending on the brands used. The values do not include optional ingredients or when ingredients are added to taste. If calorie count and other nutritional values are important to you, I recommend grabbing your favorite brands and plugging those ingredients into an online nutritional calculator.
You Might Also Like
Several years ago I was given some very soft apples. I just chunked into small pieces and cooked in microwave for a long while added spices and it was easy and so good. I even froze some in small batches. I always enjoy seeing your recipes and comments.
Thanks so much!
Can this apple butter be canned? Thanks!
I don’t see why not!
Hi Stacey
What do you think about adding a teaspoon of vanilla to your apple butter recipe? I am a huge fan of yours and I love your recipes! Thanks so much for sharing with us.
Thanks, Vikki! I sure appreciate that! I think you could absolutely include some vanilla extract. Hope it turns out great for you!
regarding adding vanilla…usually you add vanilla after cooking…take some out and give it a try…sample it. If you like it than do the whole batch.
Sounds so good. My stepfather used to add chopped pecans to the last 5 minutes of cooking time. Yum! God bless, With Wings
Sounds like a great addition! Thanks for the idea, Beth!
Hi. I mentioned to you in an earlier blog that I always used the crockpot to make apple butter in my crockpot until my friend told me you can make it in 15 minutes in an Instant Pot. I will be making mine in the Instant Pot from now on!!
I’ve got to try that for sure!
I love granny smith apples, what do you think of granny smith for this apple butter? And to the jars have to be in the refrigerator if sealed and unopened.
Sorry this is my first time to try it, and full of questions.
No worries, Mary! I’m happy to help! Granny Smith will work perfectly! When it comes to jarring/canning it, you can put it into jars and freeze it, but if you want to store it at room temp, it will have to be properly canned using the water bath method.
Can this be made with Splenda or an equivalent? I’m type 2 diabetic and would love to try it.
Seems like it should work, though I’ve not tried it myself.
If you don’t have access to good cooking apples, I’ve made really good apple butter using the large, bulk-size jars of unsweetened applesauce from Costco or Sams. Pour the applesauce straight from the jar into your slow cooker, stir in the seasonings, and cook to the desired thickness.
Great idea! Thanks for sharing that tip!!
Hi there – I just discovered your website and am trying the Orange Cake soon!
I don’t know if you have an Instant Pot (electric pressure cooker), but apple butter can be made in about an hour. I’ve made numerous batches and give them away faster than I’m able to pull them out of the water bath. It was a recipe from a co-worker than she used for years using her slow cooker and then converted it to an IP recipe. I’ve been told over and over that “This is the best apple butter I’ve ever had.” Seriously good stuff!
Looking forward to trying your recipes!
I do have an Instant Pot but haven’t tried doing apple butter in it. Thanks for the idea!
Can you substitute 100% apple juice concentrate for the sugars?
That’s not something I’ve tried, so I can’t tell you how it would turn out.
How long would you need to water bath the applesauce? Thanks again for the recipe.
Sorry, I meant Apple Butter.
About 10 minutes for half pint or pint jars.
SO delicious. Thank you for sharing. I lived in Va. years ago and I watched a friends mother make it outside in a huge black cast iron pot. Apples were cheap in those days. IT took awhile but fun to watch. Nothing taste better than homemade.
I couldn’t agree more!