Papa’s Lemon Icebox Pie

Pin this Post on Pinterest Share on Facebook

From the day I started this blog, there has always been one recipe that I wanted to share, but couldn’t.  It’s my grandfather’s recipe for Lemon Icebox Pie.  From the time I was a kid, it has always been a special treat for Papa (we pronounce it paw-paw because we’re good Southern speaking folks) to squeeze fresh lemons and make his Lemon Icebox Pie.  But in the last few years, we’ve gotten fewer and fewer pies from Papa.  You see, he developed a debilitating depression that completely changed the person he was.  The usually outgoing, fun-loving, fill-every-day-to-the-fullest man became a man that rarely ever got out of the chair.  It’s been so frustrating and sad to see what this disease has done to him – how it’s changed him into a person that I still don’t recognize.  It’s funny though, despite the fact the we all love Papa’s lemon pies, no one has ever attempted to make them.  That’s always been Papa’s job.  I’ve been asking him for the recipe for years, and I’ve never been able to get it out of him.  I’m not sure if it was the depression that made him think he couldn’t remember the recipe or it was him just not willing to let us in on the secret.  Regardless, I could have jumped on the internet and found thousands of Icebox Lemon Pie recipes – I knew most of the ingredients he used, just not the exact amounts – but I didn’t want someone else’s recipe, I wanted my Papa’s recipe.  I wanted to hear him tell me how to make it.  I wanted him to be his old self enough to tell me the recipe.  Well, this weekend… he told me the recipe.  And sure enough, the exact recipe is all over the internet and I could have been making these pies years ago.  But I didn’t want those pies, I wanted my Papa’s pies.  And now I can have them.

This disease has affected our family like nothing else ever has.  Sure he has good days and bad ones.  But we are confident that one day, we’ll have our old Papa back.  Hope and faith are about all you can count on when dealing with something like this.  I urge you if you or someone you know is battling depression, get help.  Talk to someone.

I’m telling you this pie will knock your socks off.  It is a great tart, cool summer treat!  Maybe it will become a favorite in your family too.

Ingredients

  • 1 1/2 cups Nilla Wafers, crushed (about 50 cookies)
  • 1/2 cup butter (1 stick)
  • 3 lemons, juiced
  • 1 can sweetened condensed milk (14 oz)
  • 3 eggs
  • 4 tablespoons sugar

 

Directions

  1. First, you’ll need to crush the Nilla Wafers.  You can certainly use a food processor for this, but I crushed them using my rolling pin just like my Papa’s does it. 
  2. Combine the cookie crumbs with 1 stick of melted butter.
  3. Press into the bottom and sides of a glass pie dish to form the crust.
  4. Next, separate your eggs with whites in one bowl and yolks in another.
  5. Juice the 3 lemons.  I usually run my lemon juice through a strainer to be sure there are no seeds.
  6. Combine the egg yolks, lemon juice, and sweetened condensed milk in a large bowl.  Pour into crust.
  7. Now we’re going to make our meringue topping.  I used my stand mixer for this, but you you can also use a hand mixer.  Beat the egg whites until white and frothy.
  8. Add sugar and continue beating until soft peaks form.  (Soft peaks are when the meringue is thick, but still soft enough that the peaks bend.)
  9. Spread meringue on top of filling being sure to cover entire pie to the crust with meringue.
  10. Bake in a 325 degree F oven for 15 minutes.  You can also turn on the broiler for a few minutes to toast the top of the meringue a little more if you so desire.  Just watch it closely!

Papa’s Lemon Icebox Pie

Rating: 51

Prep Time: 30 minutes

Cook Time: 12 minutes

Total Time: 42 minutes

Papa’s Lemon Icebox Pie

Ingredients

  • 1 1/2 cups Nilla Wafers, crushed (about 50 cookies)
  • 1/2 cup butter (1 stick)
  • 3 lemons, juiced
  • 1 can sweetened condensed milk (14 oz)
  • 3 eggs
  • 4 tablespoons sugar

Instructions

Crush Nilla Wafers using a food processor or by placing the cookies in a zip top bag and using a rolling pin.

Combine the cookie crumbs with 1 stick of melted butter.

Press into the bottom and sides of a glass pie dish to form the crust.

Separate your eggs with whites in one bowl and yolks in another.

Combine the egg yolks, lemon juice, and sweetened condensed milk in a large bowl. Pour into crust.

Beat the egg whites until white and frothy.

Add sugar and continue beating until soft peaks form. (Soft peaks are when the meringue is thick, but still soft enough that the peaks bend.)

Spread meringue on top of filling being sure to cover entire pie to the crust with meringue.

Bake in a 325 degree F oven for 15 minutes.

http://southernbite.com/2011/07/20/papas-lemon-icebox-pie/

email

Don't miss a single recipe! Subscribe to my email list.

Read Newer Post
«
Read Older Post
»

Comments

  1. Yum! I love Lemon Meringue Pie and I love that your papa was the piemaker in the family. My papas were not allowed to touch anything in the kitchen! :) I’m sorry about your grandfather’s depression. My grandfather, who passed away last year, suffered from dementia and was not himself for quite some time. Not the same — but I can relate in part. Thanks so much for sharing!

  2. I am soooo sorry! I’ve never had a Paw Paw. Both of mine passed away before I was born. Bless his heart! I pray he will come back to his old self again.

    Thanks so much for sharing his recipe. I am the same way about my mother’s recipes. :)

  3. I’m so very sorry to hear about you’re papa. I will be keeping him in my prayers. I could imagine it’s hard, fighting to feel ok and just can’t do it as much as you’d like to. He has y’alls love and support and the good Lord is there. I hope him sharing the recipe brought back good memories and thank you for sharing it with us. I’m gonna make it tonight cause it sure is hot, lol.

    • It was quite a special event that he shared the recipe with me. Thanks for the prayers and hopefully the pie cooled ya down a bit!

      • Stacey this pie is delicious! Enjoying my 2nd piece tonight, lol. And it was so easy, the hardest thing I had to do was separate the eggs! Thank your Papa for me and thanks again for sharing. Have a great day!

  4. peggy lewis says:

    Hey,

    Just wanted you to know I went on this blog for the first time today. I am from Montgomery, al and was reading the paper and found a recipe for okra fritters. I will be making them tonite..I love Southern cooking. pinto beans, cornbread and green onions. I could make a meal out of that alone…

    Keep these wonderful recipes coming. Love, love them!

    PM Lewis

  5. Thank you for sharing this recipe. I’m thinking it is going to taste just like my great-aunt’s lemon icebox pie! I know what it is like when a beloved relative is overcome with a disease that changes their personality; I wish all the best for you and your family.

  6. Sorry about your Papa. Our mom has dementia, so I kind of know what you are going through. It is hard.
    God bless you and thank you for the recipe.
    Linda

    • Thanks, Linda. It’s a tough thing to deal with, but we’re just taking it one day at a time. Sending prayers up for you, your mom, and your family.

  7. I know how difficult his depression has been on you all. I am glad I had the privilage of meeting the real Papa..prior to the depression.

    I have gotta try Papa’s Lemon Pie:)

  8. Would it cheer him up if we sent cards to him?

    • Sandy, your comment brought tears to my eyes. I bet he would get a kick out of cards from y’all. We’ll have to see what we can do…

  9. We’ll keep your Papa in our prayers. I’m going to try his recipe soon. Bless His Heart!

  10. LOVE your story ~ NOT the part about your Papa’s depression, I hope he is back to his old ‘self soon ~ and LOVE your Papa’s recipe, honored to add it to my recipe box and look forward to trying it!

  11. Can’t wait to try it. I love anything lemon. Your Papa sounds wonderful.

  12. Mama used to make something similar – she used a regular pie crust
    that she baked but used the same filling that your Papa used plus
    the meringue that was baked also – we loved it – about the only
    time I bake it now is when we have the kids or company over ’cause
    dh & I would eat the whole pie – Joyce

  13. Stacey, You are big time now. I just read a real nice articule about Southern Bite in the Montgomery, Alabama newspaper today. It featured the Okra Fritters. I wish everyone could read it. Great job!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  14. Cindy B. says:

    The pie look delicious. Your story really touch my heart. It reminds me to never take time for granted. I hope your papa is feeling well.

    • He has good days and bad days, but don’t we all! Thanks, Cindy and you’re right… we all should do a much better job appreciating all the small things.

  15. Stacey, congratulations for being a cooking celebrity today in the Montgomery, Alabama newspaper featuring your delicious Okra Fritters. What a great job! WOW! what a miracle you received from your PaPa this weekend, for him to actually tell you in his own words how he made his Lemon Icebox Pie after all those years of not having his recipe. The Lord works in mysterious ways, we just have to be thankful for the right moments when they come to us. I hope at that moment you had a family member to video the event between you and your PaPa with him giving you his recipe word-for-word. When most of my family was alive, I would video a lot of our family events. Now, so many have gone, but I have the videos to go back and look at and they bring me a lot of closure when I’m sad and miss them. But regardless, you have what you wanted from your Papa and that was for him to tell you in his own words how he made his pie and to me that is a miracle all in itself. I’m definitely going to make PaPa’s Lemon Icebox Pie because I love anything that is lemon and this recipe sounds yummy! You hang in there!

  16. Your Papa would be so proud of you, the pie tasted just like your Papa’s. Love to you my wonderful son !!!

  17. Taterbug says:

    Hi Stacey,

    Your story about your Papa just made me tear up. I’ve struggled with depression off and on most of my life, so I’ve got an understanding of the kind of valley he’s walking through. If there’s any way at all you could convince him to talk to a doctor or therapist about it, it’s worth trying. I know that when I finally sought help a few years ago, it completely turned my life around. Don’t ever give up on him – being surrounded by people who believed that I would get better meant the world to me, even when I couldn’t believe it for myself.

    You and your Papa will be in my prayers.

    • Thanks for your sweet comment. He’s been to doctor after doctor, has done in-patient stuff and out-patient. We just can’t seem to get him through this. But we have hope! And sometimes, that’s all you need! :-)

  18. This pie sounds great! If someone is not a huge fan of meringue, would you recommend still baking the pie for a little while, or is that only for the meringue? Normally I’m not afraid of raw eggs (I can eat cookie dough with the best of em’), but I’m pregnant and have been a little more cautious in what I eat:)

    • Hi Casey! Honestly, I’m not a huge meringue fan either, but I like this when it’s fresh. After a day, I just end up scraping the meringue off and eating the rest. The cooking is just for the meringue. It’s not necessary for the filling since the acid in the lemon does a good job of “cooking” the egg yolks. But, if you’re a little concerned, I bet it would be fine to cook it a bit. It will probably develop a film or skin on top of the filling, but probably would change the taste at all.

  19. Stacey, I’m so sorry to hear about your Papa. My heart breaks for you and your family. If you’ve read any of my work at all, you will know how important family is to me. You are doing a very noble thing by writing about your food memories. Those stories are now documented for every one and that connection will never be lost. I still make myself do ugly crying when I’m writing some of mine. I think those turn out to be some of my best work. God bless you, Stacey.

    • Jackie, thanks for your kind words. I’ve been known to do one of those ugly cries writing a post too. (Just don’t tell anyone – I wouldn’t want them to think I’m a softie!) And hey, just ignore that bad review. Remember that you’re doing this for you and your family, too, and you cannot please everyone. I’ve been there, I know what it feels like. Just trust that you’re doing what you’re supposed to be doing and know that critics are frequently like legless men trying to teach running. :-)

  20. mary barrow says:

    Stacey I love your PaPa too..he was always my fav. uncle and what has happened to him has broke my heart..but I know he is, was and always will be proud of you…keep the receips coming I remember so many from my childhood like this pie..mary b.

  21. i MADE THE LEMON ICE BOX IT DIDN.T TURN WHAT COULD i HAVE DONE WRONG?

  22. This is the exact pie my mama would make for me when I was a child and not feeling well. She was not much of a baker/cook, but she perfected this pie. After she died, my great aunt would always ask me to make this as it was her favorite, too! I feel for you and your family. Depression is a difficult condition that affects the entire family and frustrates everyone because they feel so helpless. I hope that your Papa’s action of giving you this recipe is a sign of improvement in his condition. I will pray for him and your family. Keep sharing these wonderful recipes that take me back to my childhood!

  23. My grandma used to make this with me as a kid. I don’t remember how soon I could eat it. lol. That’s really my question…. I know its stored in the freezer until its shortly devoured.

  24. Dru Lovett says:

    My mother made this same pie. She always baked her crust for about 10 minutes and cooled it before filling it. I made one 2 weeks ago and had to give MOST of it away to my neighbors so I wouldn’t get a sugar overload…once you’ve had this pie, you will not be happy with any other lemon pie.

  25. This pie looks so good.

    Glad to have found your website. Very sorry to hear about your grandfather. I hope that things turn round. It’s not easy growing older. In your heart you are young but when you try to do the things you used to do? Not always easy. He’s lucky that he has family who care about him.

    Hugs to you and PawPaw.

    CF

  26. Hey there, this recipe sounds great. Want to save it but the button is missing.
    Sorry about your papa. Christy Jordan had something on her site today too about depression. She thinks of it as a visiting mule named Abner.
    I know you wish there was something you could do other than pray.

  27. Was wondering about the meringue. I’m making the pie today for Thanksgiving. Should i make the filling today, and the meringue tomorrow? Will it breakdown before Thursday? Thanks for your advice.
    Janet

  28. Thanks for the reminder. My granny and I used to make these all the time when i was a little kid. Last year I started teaching my kids how to make it. We made 5 or so last year(I ate 2 by myself lol) It stays in the freezer until you are ready to eat it, even with the meringue on it te worse thing to happen would be that the meringue would condensate somehow and you have a clear sy fluid making the crust saturated in it. Even still it wont ruin the pie. BEST PIE IN THE WORLD….if you ask me.:)

  29. Just want to give a suggestion (my Mom made this for me for years when I was a kid).I have her recipe card but the lemon juice measurement had faded. Google to double check and wound up here. The card says to use a hand blender to mix egg yolks and condensed milk well then slowly add the lemon juice. The mixture will double. I remember this being the way she did it. Take Care!

  30. Wanda sharpe says:

    Stacy It is great that you have shared your grandfather’s receip! I was reared in Mississippi. I am now 81. As I remember, this receip came out when I was a small child taped to the top of the Eagle Brand Condensed Milk. The only difference is the original receip included the zest of one lemon stirred into the juice before adding. When I was pregnant for the first time my husband and I were with the military stationed in Ohio. My STONGEST craving was for this pie! I cannot tell you how many grocery stores I had to visit to find a can of Eagle Brand with this particular receip taped to the top!!! Now I live in Florida and am visiting in Texas. My son requested this pie. Thanks to your sharing your Papa’s receip I made my grown son a happy man last night!

  31. Mary Ellen Briehn says:

    Stacey, finding tihis post of yours truly made my day. This has always been one of my favorite pies, but I never could find “the original recipe”. This is it!!! I was able to get many of my mother’s recipes before her death, but this one I could never find. I remember her putting whole vanilla wafers around the pie. Not necessary, just langiappe as we say in Louisiana. Hope your “papa” is doing better. Thank you so much for sharing the memories and his recipe with us. May God bless and be with you all.

    • Thanks so much, Mary Ellen! I do remember my grandfather putting the vanilla wafers around the edge sometimes, too. I’m so glad that you found the recipe. Hopefully the first taste will bring back all those memories like it does for me.

  32. My husband LOVES lemon pie. I made this yesterday and he said it was the best he’s ever had. Believe me, he’s had a good bit of lemon pie so that’s quite the compliment. Thank you for sharing.

  33. Dru Lovett says:

    I grew up on a pie very close to this recipe. My Mother would make it if we were having company or if one of my older sisters brought her family to dinner. We used to stand in line in hopes of getting to lick the beaters when she was done….back then no one knew not to eat raw eggs…lol

  34. This post touched me so much, I was tearing up reading about your Papa because the story is so similar to mine. Growing up in South MS, my Papa worked on a boat that traveled the Mississippi and its tributaries. When he was home, he played guitar, sang, and cooked. A LOT. It was always such a treat to go visit when Papa was off work. His specialties were red shrimp gumbo and lemon icebox pie, so there are many cherished memories surrounding these particular foods for our whole family. My Papa did not suffer from depression, however when he was hit with the trifecta of mesothelioma, emphysema, and COPD he was always confined to his chair and his oxygen tank, struggling to breathe. No longer was he able to stand in the kitchen, walk around singing, play on the floor with the grandkids. No longer did he have the energy to tell funny stories or have long, meaningful conversations. He was too starved for oxygen.
    I thought that I remembered his recipe, but got online to double check my memory, and his recipe matches yours exactly. Thank you for sharing the recipe, and for sharing your Papa’s story.

    • Oh, Jennifer! Seeing parents and grandparents age is such a tough thing to deal with. I’m so glad this post touched you and that you found the recipe.

  35. My mama has been making this pie for as long as i can remember. It’s one of my favorites. Thanks for posting where everyone can enjoy it. God bless you and your Papa…(that’s how i spelled my paw paw’s name too..he passed in 2000 and i sure do miss him)

  36. Susan in Portugal says:

    Stacey! Do you know how BAD you are ?? I am a Brit living in northern Portugal in a heatwave – it’s over 116˚ outside …has been on and off for days and is forecast for a few more – so I was looking online for a few COOL recipes … and LOVE Lemon Meringue Pie [Brit version - we cook the custard first] and saw your ‘Ice Box Pie’ – we don’t have those so it intrigued me .. especially the idea of ICE in this weather !!!

    I love your recipe – and am going to make this asap with my own lemons….. and then I am going to make it with my limes too .. I adore limes !!!

    But you are BAD because I then thought to go over to the Eagle Brand site – and look up recipes there for condensed milk [condensed milk is used a LOT in Portuguese desserts] and now …. I am quite sure I will be piling on the pounds !!! lol!!!

    I hope your grandfather is better – it’s so sad to see our loved ones go downhill. Much love to him and yourself.

    • Thanks so much, Susan! I love to hear from the folks on the other side of the computer and I truly enjoyed you sharing with me. I hope you’ll enjoy both the lemon and lime versions. I know we sure do. Sorry for being a bad influence. Hopefully y’all will get some relief from those high temps. We experience some pretty high summer time temps here too, but not usually that bad. Our biggest problem is the terrible humidity!

  37. Tammy Hill says:

    Hey girl, great recipe. I am going to use it tonight. My father is 70 and has been successful with his Depression for 25 years. He has a secret Peanut Butter Brittle Recipe and I need to get it from him. Happy 2014 and my best to your Paw Paw.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Lemon Icebox Pie by Southern Bite.  My mother-in-law turned me on to this dessert.  It’s like eating a tall, sweet glass of lemonade. [...]

Leave a Comment

*