We’ve all got a favorite one of those fried chicken finger places. And the truth is, the best part about them is the sauce that comes with the chicken. Well, now you can make it at home! This quick and easy sauce is GREAT with chicken fingers and just about anything else you can imagine – french fries, fresh veggies, salads, seafood, anything fried, the list goes on and on… Apparently, this is a Mississippi thing, but we love it next door in Bama, too. The one thing to watch out here is for the chili sauce. Check out the photo of the ingredients – this ain’t no hot chili pepper stuff.
Ingredients
- 3/4 cup mayonnaise
- 1/3 cup chili sauce
- 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
- 1/2 teaspoon black pepper
- 1/4 teaspoon onion powder
Instructions
- Combine ingredients and refrigerate several hours to allow flavors to develop. Serve with everything!
Recipe Card
Comeback Sauce
Ingredients
- 3/4 cup mayonnaise
- 1/3 cup chili sauce
- 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
- 1/2 teaspoon black pepper
- 1/4 teaspoon onion powder
Instructions
- Combine ingredients and refrigerate several hours to allow flavors to develop. Serve with everything!
Please note:
If nutritional values are provided, they are an estimate and will vary depending on the brands used. If calorie count and other nutritional values are important to you, I recommend grabbing your favorite brands and plugging those ingredients into an online nutritional calculator.
OMGCB when I was stationed at Tyndall AFB in the 70s there was a restaurant we would go to in Tallahassee the Silver Slipper. They served a salad dressing called Comeback dressing – loved it and I’m going to make this for salad and YES fried chicken. I think it would be good on fried shrimp too! Thanks Stacey!!!
Absolutely! Hope you enjoy this!
I love your recipes! You cook like an old soul – more like my mom cooked and now I cook.
Your recipes look so amazing and makes me want to make everything you post!
This is an amazing comment! Thank you so much Joy!
Made this sauce together with your almost famous fried chicken recipe today. Just used sriracha instead of the Heinz chilli sauce, because that’s what I had at home and since my wife’s from Thailand, we both like it hot. It’s a perfect sauce for dipping or putting it on some chicken burger! Thanks for the recipe.
Glad to hear y’all enjoyed it!
Try a Tbsp of brown sugar and a scant tsp of curry powder! Great on sweet potato fries!
Hi Stacey, I made this sauce on the weekend and loved the result!
I tweaked the recipe a little bit by adding a pinch of sugar, a splash of lime juice and some ground dried chilis for kick.
Keep up the great work!
Glad you enjoyed it!
I have never understood the appeal of this mayonnaise concoction but it was intended as a salad dressing and is definitely NOT for fried chicken!
I know a WHOLE lot of people who would beg to differ. Let’s not be critical just because it’s not your choice.
Stacey, Perfect response!
I’m not a mayo guy either, but sour cream is a great substitute!
Great tip! Thanks!
If it taste good then it is for dipping if that is what one chooses to do with it. Get some new taste buds or treat the ones you have. They may even thank you.
Who gives a rats petunia what it’s intended for…its good, a LOT of people like it. Your comments are not welcome here !
Sounds yummy! Can you fix your typos? *top into to? Sorry ocd…
Got it. Thanks!
How do I make this spicy?
You can add in some ground red pepper or even some sriracha to give it a kick.
I add Pick a Pepper Sauce to jack it up a notch. In the 1950’s the local Drive In Hamburger joint near the Univ.of Florida served it in medicine bottles and added Pick a Pepper Sauce and chopped dill pickles. Talk about good!
Utah calls this fry sauce. Invented in 1948 by Artic Circle. Migrated up to Idaho and parts of the NW. When did Missisippi come up with this? Just curious.
You’re guess is as good as mine. Here’s what I know about the stuff: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comeback_sauce
I’ve used a lot of your recipes and liked them, but I think Jackie Garvin of Syrup and Biscuits has the best recipe for Comeback Sauce. https://syrupandbiscuits.com/comeback-sauce/
How long will the sauce stay fresh in the refrigerator?
I usually don’t keep it for more than a week or two… if it lasts that long.
This sounds wonderful. I usually dip my french fries in ranch dressing. Now, I have a new sauce to use on just about everything. Can’t wait to try it.
Is this sauce very spicy? My wife doesn’t like anything that is the least bit hot.
Is there a substitute I can use for the Chili Sauce?
Terry, the sauce isn’t spicy at all. If you use just Heinz chili sauce, it’s just like flavorful ketchup. There’s no heat at all.
And the Duke’s Mayonnaise!
Sounds like the “fry sauce” they use in Idaho…..SO good!!! Definitely going to have to try it!
There are lots of variations out there. I hope you enjoy this one, too!!
I make a mixture of Mayo, Ketchup, Mustard and Tabasco Sauce or hot sauce of you choice. Whatever I have left I place in the fridge for later.
Yum!
This looks SO good, Stacey!! Now, I have one grocery store in town, and I know that there’s a Heinz chili sauce that’s usually w/ the ketchup, cocktail sauce, etc. Is that what I need to get?
Yep, get the Heinz Chili sauce. Enjoy!
This sauce is so good with deep fried pickles! almost duplicates what they serve in some restaurants !
This sounds so good for an ex Californian now living in Texas. I will make it for lunch today, Thank You for such a great sounding recipe.
I hope you enjoy it, Marie!
I made this today. We did discover that if company is coming I will need to double the recipe. It will definitely be at all of our bowkl game parties!
That’s great! I’m so glad y’all enjoyed it!
I have been making a similar sauce. I add poppyseeds. Good sauce like yours makes even so-so chicken better. Thanks.
8please post your recipe with poppyseeds.??
Cant wait to try this recipe!! Stacy, you always have the best recipes!
Thanks so much, Rebekah!! I love following all your success on Facebook!!
Good for dipping French fries took!
Absolutely!!!
You’re right, it sure is a Mississippi invention, though we include a few other ingredients over here. It truly is a very versatile sauce that is good on pretty much everything, but especially our beloved seafood!
And I LOVE you Mississippians for it, too! I originally tested this as nothing but a chicken finger sauce, but now that I’ve started trying it on other stuff, I want it on everything! It’s awesome!