Classic Sweet Potato Pie is a sweet and savory dessert and the perfect comfort food. This recipe features simple ingredients and loads of flavor!
Sometimes the old school recipes with simple classic flavors are the best. And that’s exactly what this Sweet Potato Pie is… simple, classic, comforting, and flavorful. This fall favorite is made with roasted sweet potatoes, butter, evaporated milk (the secret ingredient), brown sugar, and a blend of warm fall spices. It tastes pretty close to pumpkin pie, but with a bit of a milder flavor that I much prefer.
What is Sweet Potato Pie?
Sweet potato pie is a favorite southern dessert served any time of year but mostly during the crisp, fall months and holiday gatherings. This dessert pie features a filling of mashed sweet potatoes, sugar, milk or cream, eggs, and spices, like cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger. Then it is poured into a pastry or graham cracker crust and baked in the oven.
As compared to pumpkin pie, sweet potato pie is sweeter in flavor than the pumpkin pie. It is also typically lighter in density and more of a custard-like consistency than pumpkin pie.
Why should you use evaporated milk?
For me, using evaporated milk in this is a must. Some folks refer to it as Carnation milk or canned milk. Now, this is not the same thing as sweetened condensed milk – which my grandmother still calls “Eagle Brand Milk.”
While they both are concentrated milks, sweetened condensed milk is sweetened – just as the name implies. Evaporated milk, on the other hand, is concentrated but no extra sugar is added. It is also denser and creamier than regular milk, and it has a slightly caramelized flavor because of the high heat at which it is cooked.
Evaporated milk makes this pie super rich and creamy. That said, if you can’t get your hands on a can of evaporated milk, heavy cream will work as a substitute.
Ingredient FAQs
Sweet Potatoes – Now, my recipe calls for you to roast the sweet potatoes to get them cooked before they go into the pie filling. Many recipes, though, call for you to boil them. Either way will work just fine. I just think I prefer the flavor of them better when they’ve been roasted.
Light brown sugar – Pack it down y’all! No skimping on the sugar!
Eggs – Let your eggs sit out to warm to room temperature before you begin your mixture. This allows the eggs to more easily mix in with the other ingredients.
Butter – I recommend unsalted butter, but if all you have is salted butter… don’t let that get in the way of you and this delicious dessert!
Evaporated milk – I know it sounds like an odd choice, but trust me on this one. And, if you want my reasoning behind using evaporated milk, check out the section above.
Cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and salt – You can use whatever brand you have on-hand or can easily find in the baking and spice aisle of your local grocery store.
Vanilla extract – Any brand will do. Just make sure you have at least 1 teaspoon.
Pie crust – I suggest a 9-inch unbaked deep dish pie crust.
Whipped topping – Some may decline it, but I’m definitely not some. If a dollop of Cool Whip on the top of my sweet potato pie is wrong, I don’t want to be right. Or even better… marshmallow cream! Hit the top with a blow torch to get it all toasty… Wooo, doggie, that’s some good stuff right there! Y’all enjoy!
If you tried this Classic Sweet Potato Pie recipe, please leave a 🌟 star rating and let me know how it turned out in the comments below.
Recipe Card
Classic Sweet Potato Pie
Ingredients
- 1 pound sweet potatoes
- 1 cup firmly packed light brown sugar
- 2 large eggs
- 1/2 cup butter, melted
- 1 (5-ounce) can evaporated milk
- 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
- 1/4 teaspoon ground ginger
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 (9-inch) unbaked deep dish pie crust
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 425° and line a rimmed baking sheet it aluminum foil. Wash the sweet potatoes and prick them a few times with a fork. Place them on the baking sheet and bake for about 45 minutes or until tender. Remove from the oven and allow to cool enough to handle. Peel the potatoes when cool.
- Using a mixer, mash the potatoes until smooth. Add the sugar, eggs, and melted butter and mix to combine. Add the evaporated milk, cinnamon, nutmeg, giner, salt, and vanilla and mix until combined and smooth.
- Reduce the oven temperature to 350°F. Place the unbaked pie crust on a foil lined, rimmed baking sheet. Pour the pie filling into the crust and bake in the center of the oven for 55 to 60 minutes, or until the pie is set and a toothpick inserted in the center comes out mostly clean. Allow the pie to cool. It may sink some as it cools. Refrigerate if desired. Serve topped with whipped cream or toasted marshmallow cream, if desired.
Nutrition
Please note:
If nutritional values are provided, they are an estimate and will vary depending on the brands used. If calorie count and other nutritional values are important to you, I recommend grabbing your favorite brands and plugging those ingredients into an online nutritional calculator.
How many actual potatoes do you need to use?
It honestly depends on the size of the potato. Two to three medium sweet potatoes, would be my guess.
This pie is SO GOOD. Almost too sweet but so much flavor. I put everything in a blender to get it smooth and poured it right into a gluten free crust, so easy. Also a good tip is to blend it all up except for the eggs, taste for spices, then add them in. Thank you!!
So glad you enjoyed it!
This is a wonderful recipe Stacey and you are right … roasting the sweets give them a depth of flavor much better than boiling…. as Mama said , to each his own but we know better.. right? LOL.
This gave a me a chuckle this morning. 🙂
I’ve been know to be a tad arrogant but seriously… they are better roasted. Have a Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours!!
I accidentally baked my frozen pie crust for 10 min. Can I still bake it with the filling in it for the same amount of time?
Yes. If you find the crust to start getting too dark, you can always cover it with a pie shield or a few strips of aluminum foil.
This pie looks perfect and smells delicious. Can’t wait to serve it up to those I love and love to cook for.
Hope it tasted as good as it looked and smelled!
Stacey,
Sweet potato pie was a standard in my family, especially for holidays! My grandmother always added about 1/4-1/2 tsp almond flavoring in addition to the vanilla.
I sure do love some almond flavoring. I’ll have to try that!
I love this recipe. But I prefer to peel and boil the potatoes. Roasting in the oven is messy because they tend to drip. I use a lot of sweet potatoes because I make more than one pie at a time
t certainly works to do it that way. 🙂
Love all your recipes!!
Thank you, Mary!
Riquisimo
Thanks!
Wonderful recipe. I made it with a gluten free pie crust and it was perfect! Definitely a keeper.
Thank you for sharing.
Thank you so much!
Thank you for sharing! I made it today and my husband and I loved It!
I’ll sure make it again!
Glad to hear it!
Stacey,
Could you or any of your cooking friends provide me with high altitude adjustments for your pie? I used to have a recipe for Denver that used Vanilla Butter Nut extract but I lost it and it was much like your recipe. I live at 6200 feet in Morrison, Colorado. Thanks for the help.
Katherine
I don’t have much experience with high altitude cooking, but maybe someone else can help out.
This is pretty much my recipe except I add a little honey, extra butter and a little of either orange juice or lemon juice. I prefer lemon. I also mix my sugars. Half light and half dark. I don’t really know why the honey, juices or dark sugar. But that’s how I was taught to do it and it’s delicious! The dark sugar does give it a nice color and richer flavor and the juice adds a freshness. The honey and extra butter gives it a nice shiny top and makes it taste richer. I learned long ago that’s it’s better and easier to roast the potatoes! Happy Thanksgiving!🦃
I forgot. I also add vanilla!😋
Thanks so much for sharing your tips and tricks! Happy Thanksgiving!
🦃🙏🏽🤗
Recipe looks great . Do I need to thaw the pie crust before baking . Will that change the baking time ?
They thaw pretty quickly, so it’s usually thawed by the time you pour in the filling. Enjoy!
Absolutely, the first sweet potato pie recipe that resembles my grandma’s. I was beginning to think my grandma was the only one who could make the best pie ever. She never wrote anything down I just called her and went by taste. And, now I’m the only person in our family who can replicate her strawberry cake.
This is my favorite comment of the day! Thanks so much, Renee!!
That is not a deep dish pie crust in the picture. I’m confused! Deep or not. Sounds good and want to try as a surprise for a relative who remembers it fondly as a favorite in her household. Thanks. Anne.
dunvegan21@gmail.com
Hi Anne! It is. A deep dish pie crust is what you’ll need to ensure it doesn’t overflow. Hope your relative enjoys it!
Got everything mixed up pretty golden color . I want to know excluding the sugar cani double this recipe? Seem like too many potatoes. So,
can I double the spice
I’m not 100% sure I understand the question. You can certainly double it, but you’d want to make two pies. If you just double the filling, it will create too much filling for the one crust.
I made this pie last night with a few adjustments. I live at 4800 ft. Altitude adjustments are not uncommon for me. I added a TBS of flour to help thicken up the pie. I also separated the egg whites and beat them till they formed soft peaks. I added the yolks to the whites. I folded the eggs into the sweet potato mixture last. The pie was wonderful. Light, set by 58 minutes of baking and the best I have ever eaten. No more store bought pie for me.
So glad to hear it turned out great for you!!
I live in colorado at 6200 feet would the adjustments you used be the same for me?
Thanks
Katherine
I made this recipe and yes, 425 degrees for 55 minutes was perfect in my oven. And I must say this is the best sweet potato pie I have ever had!! Thank you Stacey for this wonderful recipe.
I do have a tip though, my new container of nutmeg clumped a little because I added my spices after adding the milk and it did not incorporate as well as it should’ve if I had added them at the proper time. And I will also blend my spices together before adding them to the filling, I think it would help to keep any of them from clumping.
I’m so glad it turned out well for you, Brenda! So glad you enjoyed it and thanks for sharing those tips.
The best sweet potato pie! My family loved it. It was such an easy recipe to follow. I will definitely be making another one for Thanksgiving.
Aww! Thanks, Kathleen! So glad to hear y’all enjoyed it!
Hello Brenda, just a tip for you. Use fresh nutmeg not nutmeg from the container. As soon as you open that container the nutmeg will begin to lose flavor. Buy a jar of nutmeg nuts, get a small grater and grate them. You won’t regret it. And be careful not to use a lot of fresh nutmeg, it’s a stronger spice but oh so worth it for the flavor.
So really, you cook the pie at 425 degrees for 50-60 minute? Seems mighty high for so long.
Brenda you bake the sweet potatoes in the oven at 425 degrees and when the potatoes are done you reduce your oven temp. to 350 degrees to bake the sweet potato pie.
Hello Stacey I Will Be Trying This Sweet potatoes Pie And The Pineapple Juice Cake I Will Let You Know If The Family Keep Me Or Say Bye Bye????
Something tells me they’re gonna keep you! Enjoy!
How can I print this Sweet Potato Pie recipe?
Simply click the “Print Recipe” button in the upper right hand corner of the recipe card towards the bottom of the post.
Hi Stacey,
This recipe sounds like something I am craving tonight. I think sweet potato is my favorite pie! Could you guesstimate how many cups of cooked sweet potato would make this recipe. I already roasted my potatoes today and wonder if I could use a pound of the cooked or would it be a pound of potatoes before cooked? Thanks for any help. The potatoes are so good plain that they will for sure make a great pie!
Thanks for all these wonderful recipes!!!
Carolyn
Hi Carolyn! I would guess between 2 and 21/2 cups of cooked sweet potato. Sure hope you’ll enjoy it!
Hi Stacey! Can ya; see me wavin’ at ya’ from GA? LOL Could you please tell me if you used salted or unsalted butter in this? Your recipe is very much like mine, and I use the salted kind, only diff is the 3 spices. I’m going to be really adventurous and add them thar’ spices next time and I know it will be tummy- yummy. Never occurred to me to use them except in pumpkin pie (now ain’t I in a rut?). When cooking for my parents I always stuck to Mom’s old fashioned recipe I’d always made. They loved the plain sweet potato flavor that came through and I did too, but it’s time for a change. Thanks SO much for sharing another of your great recipes.
Hugs & Blessings to all,
Linda
Hey over there!! I use unsalted, but either will work. When I have a recipe where it makes a big difference, I try to specify. If it’s not super important, I usually just say “butter.” Hope you’ll enjoy it and hugs to y’all, too!
Okay, you have redeemed yourself with this recipe. This is (for sure) Pie, not some other name like: Pumpkin Pudding (maybe). He he he … No, that was cornbread or more cake-biscuits … not Biscuits in a pan. Come on, Stacey, Man. That was so confusing in your other recipe …
Well, I’m glad to hear that. Though, I assure you no cornmeal was used in that other recipe so there’s no way it could have been cornbread! LOL! 🙂